Session 5: Peer Review

Friday 2 June 2023 – 2.30pm-4.00pm (Turkish time)

 

Session 5.1 Reducing prestige bias in peer review with voluntary anonymization

In this session, the chair set the scene on the current understanding of bias and quality in peer review and asked each presenter to provide their findings on the impact of transparency or lack thereof on bias and quality of reviewer comments.

Chair

Bahar Mehmani

AI Market Research Strategist EASE President, ElsevierThe Netherlands

Dr. Bahar Mehmani is AI market research strategist at Elsevier. She leads structured AI Market Research studies for Elsevier AI products, helping measure product performance against clear hypotheses, metrics, and external reference points, while translating findings into actionable insights for product and senior leadership. Bahar is an advisory member of Peer Review Congress. She is currently President of EASE.

 

Read more

Speakers

Tony Ross-Hellauer

, Graz University of Technology and Know-Center GmbHAustria

Misha Teplitskiy

Assistant professor, University of MichiganUnited States

Alessio Bolognesi

Interim Head of Journal Development, eLife Sciences PublicationsUnited Kingdom

Session 5.2: The ethics of peer review: What can go wrong?

Chair

Mario Malički

Research Scholar, Stanford UniversityUnited States

Read more

Speakers

Catriona MacCallum

Director of Open Science , Hindawi Ltd

Daniel Stuckey

Senior Publishing Ethics Expert, ElsevierUnited Kingdom

Read more

Tom Hunter

Research Integrity Manager, Frontiers